Comfortable Sandals

Published on March 28th, 2025 | by Kirsten Borrink

3

7 Comfortable Fisherman Sandals for Spring 2025

I could be late to the nautical party, but I’m crossing my fingers and winter toes that fisherman sandals are still in for 2025. The thought of a breezy yet toe-covering sandal sounds perfect for easing my feet into spring. I’ve compiled a collection of seven comfortable fisherman sandals for those of us with challenging feet, starting with my own review of the White Mountain Glove sandal.

The style is cute and overall, the sandal is a good value for the price. – Zappos customer

Try the trend without breaking the bank! The White Mountain glove fisherman sandal features a real leather upper, faux leather cushioned insole, adjustable velcro closure and 1.5″ lug sole. Arch support is minimal. Available in sizes 6-11, medium width for $39-85 from:

Leather is butter soft and the inner soles mold to your feet. Color is spot on. Feet are happy. – Nordstrom customer

A new-to-me-brand from Spain, On Foot shoes feature a contoured double-density memory foam atop a cork midsole and an anti-slip rubber outsole. Soft leather uppers and a roomy toe box make the 202 comfortable fisherman sandal a great option for bunions. A few reviews mention the shoe runs a little short. Available in medium width, euro sizes 36-41 (5.5-9.5) from:

I can’t say enough about how wonderful these shoes are. Like a lot of people I have feet issues. These shoes felt good right out of the box. No rubbing. No pressure points. My insoles fit perfectly. Plus they’re so stylish. – Ryka customer

Here’s a sporty fisherman sandal by Ryka that covers the whole forefoot (in case your pinky toe typically gets caught in straps). Ryka specializes in footwear that’s roomy at the toe and snug at the heel–great for those difficult-to-fit combination feet. Available in medium and wide widths, sizes 5-12 from:

The Aerosoles Dapper is a modern, office-appropriate take on the fisherman sandal featuring a square toe, 1.5″ block heel and real silver buckle closure. Available in medium width, sizes 5-12 from:

11 Narrow that actually fit are very hard to find (the reason why I scooped them all up immediately after reading reviews). These sandals hug and support the entire length of the foot. -Nordstrom customer

If your toes are ready to show off, consider the Munro Marley! I just read that this quality brand is sadly closing up shop, so snatch them up while you can. The Marley features moderate arch support, lightweight EVA outsole, velcro closure and microfiber cushioned insole. Available in narrow to extra wide widths, sizes 5-12 from:

These are lovely conformable sandals. I have wide feet and there is no pinching at the sides. – Fitflop customer

If you’re not a fun of the chunky lug sole, the Fitflop Gracie is for you, especially if your feet are on the wider side. The Gracie features real leather upper a real buckle (no velcro) and Fitflop’s Dynamicush™ footbed (not quite as supportive as their denser Microwobbleboard™ footbed). Available in medium width (fits wide), sizes 5-11 from:

How about a stylish yet comfortable heeled platform sandal with a fisherman aesthetic? The Earth Adona features a 2.75″ heel with a 1″ platform, cushioned insole and real buckle closure. Available in medium width, sizes 5-12 from:

Honorable mention: Check out the Earth Berri closed toe sandal featured here–it has a fisherman look to it with tons of great reviews for all-day comfort.

Related Posts

Crocs Brooklyn Cork Buckle Sandals Review →

Sandals With Arch Support: 9 Picks for Sure Comfort All Summer Long →

Reader Request: 5 Plantar Fasciitis Sandals with Style and Support →

Taos Super Side Sandals Review: Water and Foot-Friendly →