Published on March 15th, 2025 | by Kirsten Borrink

Merrell Moab Mid Waterproof Hiking Boots Review

The Merrell Moab 3 Mid Waterproof hiking boot is my missing puzzle piece for winter footwear. I have snow boots (The North Face Shellista), muck boots (Bogs), and a lovely pair of L.L. Bean hiking boots that are sturdy but too stiff around the ankle. I needed a pair of lightweight yet warm and supportive boots with excellent traction for the nature path I regularly take. While you can tell I love my new Merrell Moab boots in my video review, I asked my Facebook followers for their feedback. Here’s what they had to say (plus check out a summarized list of ALL their favorite hiking boots):

“Love them! I bought them a few months ago. I’ve worn them to work, local walks and snowy walks in NH and VT woods. Super comfortable to wear right out of the box. Plenty of room in the toe box to not put pressure on my ball of my foot since I have hallux rigidus.” _{Facebook follower Katie}

“Appreciate the stability they provide my foot, and also from a traction standpoint they’re great on ice/muck/rocky trails etc.” _{Facebook follower Kristi}

“I have them in a low sneaker type version. They are in my top five for trail walking. My office is in the redwoods and I love the Merrell Moab for trekking across campus on the uneven woodsy trails. I have really bad knees and these work well for me.” _{Facebook follower Kelly}

If there’s one caveat to heed while considering the Merrell Moab, it’s the sizing. Some reviews mention that it runs a little short. I considered ordering up a half size from my regular 10 (yes, Merrell carries a 10.5), but decided to keep them because I didn’t want them too roomy when I wear thinner socks come spring. However, if you plan to wear them with orthotics, I do advise ordering up a whole or half size.

The Merrell Moab 3 Mid is available in sizes 5-12, waterproof and regular uppers, medium and wide widths for $97-150 from Merrell, Zappos, Nordstrom and Amazon.

Top 20 Most Comfortable Hiking Boots Based on Comments from Barking Dog Facebook Fans 🚶‍♂️🏔:

Altra Lone Peak – Known for comfort, a wide toe box, and great traction.
“Altra Lone Peak fits the bill. I used them to hike a very wet Mt. Katahdin and also use them as my winter running shoe (boot).” – Amanda M.
Merrell Moab (Multiple Versions) – Comes in both high and low top, waterproof options, and wide sizes.
Topo Athletic Hiking Boots – Lightweight, 3mm drop, and great for natural foot positioning.
“Topo makes a NICE hiking boot which I use. FYI it is about a 3mm drop.” – Anonymous
Salomon Hiking Boots – Waterproof and orthotic-friendly.
“They are waterproof and take orthotics.” – Wanda K.
Oboz Bozeman – Lightweight, good traction, and removable insoles for orthotics. “Oboz Bozeman! Shoe and mid version… great as a lightweight and flexible trail shoe.” – Madeleine G.
Keen Targhee – Wide toe box, waterproof, and orthotic-friendly.
“I use Keens men’s Targhee. Come in wide if you need it. Ample toe box. I use orthotics and an extra heel insert.” – Whidbey M.
Hoka Speedgoat – Comfortable cushioning, wide toe box, and waterproof options.
“I use the Hoka Speedgoat or Challenger. Both are low top and come in a waterproof option.” – Anna O.
Lowa Hiking Boots – Expensive but durable, waterproof, and very comfortable for long walks.
“I love my Lowas. They’re expensive and hard to find in the US, but I can walk all day in them and they’re waterproof.” – Bea L.
North Face Vectiv – Waterproof, stiff rocker sole, and removable insoles for orthotics.
“North Face Vectiv have waterproof options, a stiff rocker sole, and removable insole to fit orthotic insoles but are very narrow.” – Vicky L.
Dansko Paisley – Orthotic-friendly and offers a higher version for more support.
“Dansko has a couple I could fit my Insoles in, one is the Paisley, there is also a higher version.” – Virginie P.
New Balance Fresh Foam X More Trail V3 – Available in wide sizes and offers good cushioning.
“I have New Balance Women’s Fresh Foam X More Trail V3 trail Running Shoe. I ordered in Wides and half larger for my inserts. Love them.” – Laura D.
Xelero Steadfast or Hyperion – Designed specifically for people with foot arthritis, provides excellent joint support.
Ariat Hiking Boots – Great for narrow heels and compatible with custom inserts.
“For a foot with a narrow heel, my Ariats work great with my inserts.” – Debra J.
LALO Tactical Boots – A rugged option for serious hikers looking for durability.
Orthofeet Dakota – Recommended for people with foot problems, designed for maximum comfort.